
Why I Chose Surrogacy: A Gay Dad's Decision
Why a single gay man chose surrogacy to become a father. The real reasons, the fears, and what nobody tells you about making the decision.
People ask me why I chose surrogacy like there was a menu of options and I picked the most expensive one. There wasn't. For a single gay man who wanted a biological connection to his children, surrogacy wasn't a choice — it was the path.
The Decision Nobody Prepares You For
I always knew I wanted to be a dad. That part was never the question. The question was how — and as a gay man, the 'how' comes with a complexity that most people never have to think about.
Adoption was on the table. Co-parenting was discussed. But surrogacy kept pulling me back. The idea of a biological connection, of seeing my family in my children's faces — that mattered to me. And I'm done apologizing for it.
The Fears That Almost Stopped Me
The cost. $150K+ is not a number you casually commit to. The legal complexity. The medical uncertainty. The idea of doing this alone, as a single parent, with no partner to share the weight.
And the fear that people would judge me. That they'd say I was selfish for bringing children into a 'non-traditional' family. That my kids would suffer for having a gay dad. Those fears were real — and they were wrong.
The World Is Theirs
A real dad's guide to traveling with kids — blowouts, layovers, and all. Free instant download.
What Made Me Say Yes
A conversation with a friend who'd done it. She said: 'The fear doesn't go away. You just decide the dream is bigger than the fear.' That stuck.
I realized I was waiting for permission — from society, from my family, from some imaginary authority — to become a parent. And nobody was going to give it to me. I had to give it to myself.
What I'd Tell Someone Considering It
Start before you're ready. You'll never feel ready. The research phase can become a procrastination phase if you let it.
Talk to gay dads who've done it. Not agencies, not lawyers — actual dads. Their stories will tell you more than any brochure.
And know this: the journey is hard. The outcome is everything.

Joseph Tito
Creator of The Dad Diaries. Gay dad of twins. Writing about fatherhood, surrogacy, and the beautiful mess of real life.