Joseph Tito with his twin daughters — why he chose surrogacy
Surrogacy Journey· January 10, 2025

Why I Chose Surrogacy: A Gay Dad's Decision

Why a single gay man chose surrogacy to become a father. The real reasons, the fears, and what nobody tells you about making the decision.

People ask me why I chose surrogacy like there was a menu of options and I picked the most expensive one. There wasn't. For a single gay man who wanted a biological connection to his children, surrogacy wasn't a choice — it was the path.

The Decision Nobody Prepares You For

I always knew I wanted to be a dad. That part was never the question. The question was how — and as a gay man, the 'how' comes with a complexity that most people never have to think about.

Adoption was on the table. Co-parenting was discussed. But surrogacy kept pulling me back. The idea of a biological connection, of seeing my family in my children's faces — that mattered to me. And I'm done apologizing for it.

The Fears That Almost Stopped Me

The cost. $150K+ is not a number you casually commit to. The legal complexity. The medical uncertainty. The idea of doing this alone, as a single parent, with no partner to share the weight.

And the fear that people would judge me. That they'd say I was selfish for bringing children into a 'non-traditional' family. That my kids would suffer for having a gay dad. Those fears were real — and they were wrong.

Free Download

The World Is Theirs

A real dad's guide to traveling with kids — blowouts, layovers, and all. Free instant download.

Get the Free Guide

What Made Me Say Yes

A conversation with a friend who'd done it. She said: 'The fear doesn't go away. You just decide the dream is bigger than the fear.' That stuck.

I realized I was waiting for permission — from society, from my family, from some imaginary authority — to become a parent. And nobody was going to give it to me. I had to give it to myself.

What I'd Tell Someone Considering It

Start before you're ready. You'll never feel ready. The research phase can become a procrastination phase if you let it.

Talk to gay dads who've done it. Not agencies, not lawyers — actual dads. Their stories will tell you more than any brochure.

And know this: the journey is hard. The outcome is everything.

Joseph Tito

Joseph Tito

Creator of The Dad Diaries. Gay dad of twins. Writing about fatherhood, surrogacy, and the beautiful mess of real life.