Joseph Tito meeting his twin daughters for the first time
Surrogacy Journey· December 5, 2018

Meeting My Baby Girls

The moment I held my daughters for the first time. Not the movie version — the real one, with all its weight and wonder.

I had imagined this moment so many times that when it actually happened, it felt both familiar and completely foreign. Like a song you've heard in your head finally played out loud — recognizable, but different in ways you couldn't have predicted.

The First Hold

They were small. Twins at 36 weeks are small. The nurses showed me how to hold them — one at a time first, then both together. My arms remembered what to do before my brain did.

Stella first. Then Mia. Then both of them, somehow, in my arms at once. Three years of trying, five transfers, one very long journey — and here they were. Real. Warm. Mine.

What I Felt

Not what I expected. I expected the movie version — the immediate, overwhelming certainty. What I felt was something quieter and stranger. A recognition. Like meeting someone you've always known.

The love came in waves. Not all at once. Over hours, over days, over the weeks that followed. Each wave bigger than the last.

Free Download

The World Is Theirs

A real dad's guide to traveling with kids — blowouts, layovers, and all. Free instant download.

Get the Free Guide

The NICU Days

They spent three days in the NICU for monitoring. I was there every hour I was allowed to be. I learned their sounds, their rhythms, their preferences. I learned that Stella was louder and Mia was more watchful.

Those three days were some of the most important of my life. Not because anything dramatic happened — but because that's where I became their father. Not in the moment of birth, but in the ordinary hours that followed.

Going Home

When they were released on December 6th, I carried them out of that hospital and into a world that had no idea what was happening. Two small people. One very overwhelmed dad. The beginning of everything.

I've never been more terrified or more certain of anything in my life.

Joseph Tito

Joseph Tito

Creator of The Dad Diaries. Gay dad of twins. Writing about fatherhood, surrogacy, and the beautiful mess of real life.