Joseph Tito reflecting on parenting judgments
Fatherhood· February 5, 2025

Things I Judged Before Becoming a Dad (And Deeply Regret Now)

Every judgment I made about other parents before I had kids — and the deep regret that came after becoming one myself.

Before I had kids, I had opinions. Strong ones. About screen time, about bedtime, about the kind of parent I'd be. Then I actually <a href="/what-changes-in-a-man-when-he-becomes-a-father">became a parent</a>. And every single opinion crumbled.

The Screen Time Judgment

I was going to be a no-screen parent. Educational toys only. Wooden blocks and nature walks. Then I discovered that 22 minutes of Bluey is the difference between cooking dinner and burning the house down. I've since written a whole piece on navigating screen time as a modern parent — because it deserves more nuance than any judgment I had before kids.

Screen time isn't lazy parenting. It's strategic parenting. And anyone who says otherwise hasn't tried to make pasta while two six-year-olds are having a meltdown.

The 'My Kids Will Eat Everything' Fantasy

I judged parents with picky eaters. I assumed it was a failure of exposure or effort. Then my daughter ate nothing but plain pasta for three months straight and I understood.

Kids have opinions. Strong, irrational, deeply held opinions about food. You can expose them to everything and they'll still choose chicken nuggets. And that's fine.

Free Download

The World Is Theirs

A real dad's guide to traveling with kids — blowouts, layovers, and all. Free instant download.

Get the Free Guide

The Patience Myth

I thought I'd be a patient parent. Calm. Zen. The dad who never raises his voice. Then sleep deprivation happened. And tantrums. And the fifteenth 'why?' in a row. That's when I understood parenting burnout on a personal level.

Patience isn't a personality trait. It's a resource. And like any resource, it runs out. The goal isn't to never lose it — it's to repair when you do.

What I've Learned

Every parent is doing their best with what they have. The judgments we make before kids are based on fantasy. The reality is messier, harder, and more beautiful than anything I imagined.

Now when I see a parent struggling in public, I don't judge. I nod. Because I've been there. We all have.

Joseph Tito

Joseph Tito

Creator of The Dad Diaries. Gay dad of twins. Writing about fatherhood, surrogacy, and the beautiful mess of real life.